Spirit Research

A cancer survivorship trial links mindfulness and tai chi to changes in symptoms

A trial of more than 500 cancer survivors found changes in fatigue, sleep problems and the effect of pain on daily life after mindfulness or tai chi and qigong programs, Medical Dialogues reports. The participants had a range of cancer types and stages, and the study appeared in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.

The Mindfulness and Tai Chi for Cancer Health trial compared the programs with a waitlist group, according to BIOENGINEER. Participants could choose a practice, while those without a preference were assigned one. The study was a collaboration involving the University of Calgary, the University of Toronto and Mass General Brigham.

Published

The trial measured pain in two ways#

Both programs were associated with improvements in fatigue and pain interference, a measure of how much pain disrupts daily activities, BIOENGINEER reports. Participants practicing tai chi and qigong saw particularly notable improvements in sleep disturbance. The researchers found minimal effects on pain intensity, a separate measure.

The mindfulness program combined meditation, breathing, gentle stretching and group discussion, according to Medical Dialogues. Tai chi and qigong, Chinese mind-body practices, combined flowing movements with attention to breathing and bodily sensations. Lead investigator Linda E. Carlson said the findings could start a conversation about incorporating such practices into cancer care.

Other reviews found mixed results#

A separate review of 39 studies found that most reported better sleep quality or less insomnia among women with cancer who took part in mindfulness programs, the European Medical Journal reports. The review included 24 randomized controlled trials, and most participants were survivors who had completed treatment.

The findings were not uniform, according to the European Medical Journal. Some studies found no difference between groups even when participants in the mindfulness group improved. Results from actigraphy, a way of measuring sleep, varied more than questionnaire results, and pain findings were mixed.

A review of randomized trials in breast cancer survivors found improvements in shoulder movement and physical fatigue among participants assigned to tai chi, BIOENGINEER reports. The analysis found no statistically significant differences in shoulder pain, muscle strength or the ability to carry out daily activities.

The authors of the sleep review called for standardized trials designed to investigate how mindfulness programs work, according to the European Medical Journal. The review found that few studies measured biological markers and that their results were inconsistent.

Discover more