Alabama’s Third Nitrogen Gas Execution Faces Legal Hurdle

A federal judge in Alabama is considering a request to block the state’s third nitrogen gas execution, as concerns grow over the method’s humaneness after two prior executions caused visible distress.

Alabama’s Third Nitrogen Gas Execution Faces Legal Hurdle
by Shukriya Shahi - October 9, 2024, 2:59 am

A federal judge is reviewing Alabama’s request to carry out a third nitrogen gas execution, set for November 21. Attorneys for inmate Carey Dale Grayson are asking for a preliminary injunction, arguing that the current execution protocol has significant flaws that must be addressed before proceeding.

Concerns Over Past Executions

Alabama has conducted two nitrogen gas executions so far, with media witnesses reporting disturbing physical reactions. The inmates were seen shaking and taking labored breaths for several minutes, raising questions about whether the method delivers the quick death that was initially promised.

How Nitrogen Gas Execution Works

The execution involves placing a respirator mask on the inmate’s face, replacing breathable air with nitrogen gas, which causes death by oxygen deprivation. Critics argue that the process is inhumane and needs to be reevaluated.

State’s Response

Alabama Corrections Commissioner John Q. Hamm defended the method, stating that involuntary movements and labored breathing were expected. The state is asking the judge to allow the execution to proceed without changes.

Awaiting the Judge’s Decision

The federal judge will decide whether to block the execution or allow Alabama to move forward with its third use of nitrogen gas, as the debate continues over the ethics and effectiveness of this execution method.